Pulled Pork Finishing Sauce Recipe

Pulled pork finishing sauce

Pulled Pork is one of the most popular pork-based dishes in the United States.

Originated in the Southern region of the U.S.A, this staple of sweet and savory goodness consists of slow-cooking a pork shoulder at low, indirect heat. Using this method helps the meat preserve its natural juice and tenderness.

Once cooked and pulled, using Cave Tools Pulled Pork Shredder Rakes, the meat is rich and saturated enough to pull apart with the help of meat claws, or even with fork and knife.

The result is a generous portion of meaty, juicy, tender, smoky strings of pork that can be mixed with a finishing sauce to create a delicious plate.

"Finishing" Sauce

Contrary to what its name may imply, a “finishing sauce” refers to any kind of sauce used on dishes either during or after the cooking process.

This said, any sauce that is added to food after the dish is served is considered a “finishing sauce.”

For example, meat sauce can be considered a finishing sauce since it is added to spaghetti after the noodles are cooked. Similarly, buffalo sauce can be considered a “finishing sauce” since it is tossed on chicken wings after they are finished frying and cooling off.

Pulled Pork Finishing Sauce

Now, in the case of pulled pork, paying close attention to the confection of the finishing sauce is just as important as the rest of the cooking process. There are region-wide competitions dedicated to finding the perfect finishing sauce for pulled pork. It is kind of a big deal!

This is because the finishing sauce can change the entire essence of the plate. Even though pulled pork is typically smoky and delicious enough to eat on its own, the sauce will bring an entirely new dimension of punch and flavor that is unequal to any other Southern BBQ dish.

Types of sauces for pulled pork

Types of Pulled Pork Finishing Sauces and How to Make Them

Finishing sauces for pulled pork are as varied as they are interesting. Like BBQ sauce, pulled pork finishing sauce recipes include cultural and regional variations that represent the people who worked so very hard every day trying to make something truly extraordinary.

Here are some of the most popular pulled pork finishing sauce recipes:

Vinegar-based finishing sauces- This finishing sauce is known as the Carolina-based finishing sauce. The South Carolina version is vinegar-mustard based. The North Carolina version is vinegar-ketchup based. They vary as far as additional ingredients, but they are the same in that they both include honey, sugar, and spices. As far as all other ingredients, it is entirely up to the chef what else goes in it.

Mayo-Horseradish based finishing sauces- This refers to the famous Big Bob Gibson’s Alabama White Sauce, originally from Decatur, AL. This sauce gives a savory-buttery finish to pulled pork to satisfy those fans who aren’t too much into the “sweet stuff.”

As a zero-sugar based sauce, this option is great for keto dieters.

Nashville, TN boasts a similar sauce that they also call “white,” but is actually a blush-like color. The reason for this is the addition of cayenne pepper and paprika to make them different. However, the Alabama White Sauce tradition is quite strong in the South as well, earning it its very own spot in the sauce hall of fame.

Molasses-based finishing sauce- This is perhaps one of the most popular pulled pork finishing sauce recipes, without a doubt. How could it not be? It is smoky, sticky, thick, sweet, and delicious. Its sweet and tangy flavor begs you to go back for seconds with its finger licking goodness. Think BBQ sauce on steroids.

Good ol’ Sloppy Joe- Hey, let’s not beat a traditional Sloppy Joe finishing sauce, even when it is typically used for ground beef. The base for Sloppy Joe finishing sauce is no different than any other regular home-made BBQ sauce. It is a tomato-based sauce made with ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, dijon mustard or Grey Poupon, brown sugar, salt and pepper.

No-Brainer Pulled Pork Finishing Sauce Recipe

After talking about pulled pork so much, let’s focus on one pulled pork finishing sauce recipe: Molasses-based pulled pork finishing sauce.

We chose to focus on this recipe because it is quite delicious and rich. As such, you still need to keep some balance among all the ingredients. This way, the sauce won’t turn out too overpoweringly sweet, or sticky.

Here are the ingredients you will need for ONE CUP of molasses-based pulled pork finishing sauce. Double up as you go, for more sauce.

  • 1 can tomato sauce; you can swap for tomato paste
  • 1/3 cup raw honey, or pure molasses
  • 1/4 cup white vinegar; try red wine vinegar if you prefer a more tangy flavor
  • 1 tbsp adobo (If you do not have adobo, make a mixture of 1 teaspoon each chili powder, sea salt, black pepper, garlic powder.)
  • 1 tsp cinnamon
Homemade sauce for pork


-Get a mixing bowl and combine all the ingredients. Mix thoroughly.

-Add all ingredients to a saucepan. Bring to a boil, and then reduce to low heat. Simmer for about 10 minutes.

-Apply the sauce to the pulled pork while it is still warm, after cooking. Mix through, and keep another batch for when you come for seconds. Believe us, you will need it.

How to serve a balanced plate with pulled pork and finishing sauce?

For this recipe, we went all the way to the top of the range in the “sweet and tangy” category. We believe this is the world’s favorite way to eat BBQ, due to its sweetness and finger licking stickiness.

This said, you want to pair a pulled pork sweet BBQ plate with foods of the exact opposite flavor. This will not take away the star status of the pulled pork flavor.

Also, try not to bulk up too much on starchy side dishes so that you can save room for more meat! We were born carnivores for a good reason!

Here are some light, fresh and savory ideas:

  • Roasted asparagus wrapped in bacon
  • Roasted veggies, such as tomatoes, zucchini, and squash
  • Butter noodles (or spiralized veggie noodles) in white cream sauce (Alfredo)
  • Oven-fried, homemade potato chips
  • Oven fries with salt and vinegar
  • Chopped house salad with seasonal veggies and creamy Alabama white sauce as dressing
  • Roasted Garlic bread rounds lightly seasoned with sea salt. Dip on the finishing sauce for extra flavor
  • Black beans, instead of baked beans



Pair sweet pulled pork with a refreshing drink to cleanse your palate in between bites:

  • Crisp apple cider
  • Orange-based Belgium lager with a wedge of fresh orange squeezed in (such as Blue Moon)
  • Crisp, dry rose wine, such as Rose Brut, or Pinot Noir blush
  • Crisp, dry white wine,such as Sauvignon Blanc or Pinot Grigio
  • Seltzer (soda) water combined with fresh, squeezed lime juice, a dash of sugar and crushed mint (virgin Mojito)
  • Add white rum to the virgin Mojito to make it a proper Mojito
Pulled pork diah

Wrap it Up!

Pulled pork is a go-to meal that is as fun to make as it is to eat. Slow roasting the pork shoulder to perfection is relaxing and so worth it. You get enough food to feed a whole family, but they you also get the chance to play around with the different flavors you want to use on your pork.

Whether you go Carolina-based, Alabama-based, sweet, savory, or traditional BBQ, pulled pork will give you the best meat to experiment with, at zero risk. The meat itself is delicious on its own. What you bring to the recipe is a very welcomed extra! Do you have a favorite pulled pork finishing sauce recipe?

Win a Free Steak Dinner on Us!

Every month we give away two free 14 Day Dry Aged Rib Eye Steaks

Entering the contest takes less than 5 minutes and then you’re eligible to win every single month from then on


Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on reddit
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest